Just weeks ago, Penn State stood on the brink of college football glory, their sights set on a national championship. But in a stunning turn of events, the program has fired head coach James Franklin, leaving fans and analysts alike reeling. What went wrong, and who will step into the void? Let’s dive into the dramatic downfall, the potential successors, and the players who could shape Penn State’s future.
James Franklin’s abrupt exit is nothing short of historic. After more than a decade at the helm, his tenure ended with a series of crushing defeats—first to Oregon, then to underdog teams like UCLA and Northwestern. But here’s where it gets controversial: Was it the losses themselves, or the way they exposed deeper issues within the program, that sealed his fate? A season-ending injury to star quarterback Drew Allar against Northwestern only added salt to the wound, leaving Happy Valley in a state of despair.
Franklin’s fall from grace is particularly jarring when you consider that just last year, Penn State was on the cusp of a national championship, losing only in overtime to Notre Dame in the CFP semifinals. This season was supposed to be championship-or-bust, but instead, it’s been a bust of monumental proportions. And this is the part most people miss: Despite his successes, Franklin’s inability to consistently deliver in high-stakes games made it increasingly difficult to envision a future with him at the helm.
Now, Penn State must chart a new course. With significant investments in facilities, NIL deals, and other resources, the program is poised to attract top-tier talent. Athletic director Patrick Kraft, a football aficionado with championship aspirations, will play a pivotal role in selecting the next leader. Penn State’s access to recruits in the Northeast, Mid-Atlantic, and Midwest ensures they can compete at the highest level—but only if they make the right hire.
So, who’s in the running? Here are five candidates who could step into Franklin’s shoes, each bringing their own unique strengths and potential controversies:
Matt Rhule (Nebraska Coach): A former Nittany Lion himself, Rhule’s connection to Penn State runs deep. He played linebacker and later worked under Kraft at Temple, where he turned the program around. But here’s the catch: Their close friendship might actually work against him. Would Kraft risk their relationship for a shot at a national title? Rhule’s success at Baylor and Temple, coupled with Nebraska’s resurgence under his leadership, makes him a compelling choice—but can he deliver a championship in Happy Valley?
Curt Cignetti (Indiana Coach): A move that would shake up the Big Ten, Cignetti has defied expectations at Indiana, transforming a perennial bottom-feeder into a contender. His ties to regional rivals like Pitt and West Virginia could raise eyebrows, but his track record of winning big—including a 53-17 stint at Indiana University-Pennsylvania—speaks for itself. At 64, this could be his last chance to lead a program with national title aspirations. But is Penn State ready to take a gamble on a coach with no direct ties to Kraft?
Matt Campbell (Iowa State Coach): A perennial name on coaching shortlists, Campbell has built Iowa State into a Big 12 powerhouse. His offensive prowess and quarterback development could be exactly what Penn State needs after Franklin’s inconsistent offense. However, his loyalty to Iowa State has kept him from making a move thus far. Is now the time for Campbell to take the leap, or will he remain loyal to the program he’s built?
Manny Diaz (Duke Coach): Diaz’s tenure at Miami ended on a sour note, but his time as Penn State’s defensive coordinator in 2022-2023 was nothing short of stellar. He transformed the Lions’ defense into a national powerhouse before heading to Duke, where he’s thrived. His aggressive defensive philosophy and East Coast recruiting ties make him an intriguing option. But can he overcome the stigma of his Miami exit and bring a new energy to Happy Valley?
Dan Mullen (UNLV Coach): Mullen’s 6-0 start at UNLV has turned heads, but his Florida tenure ended abruptly. Despite a 34-15 record with the Gators, questions remain about his ability to lead a top-tier program. A Pennsylvania native with a knack for developing quarterbacks, Mullen could be a dark horse candidate. But is his past enough to convince Penn State he’s the right man for the job?
As Penn State navigates this coaching transition, retaining key players will be crucial. Here are five athletes who could shape the program’s future:
- DE Chaz Coleman: A true freshman with NFL potential, Coleman’s 11 pressures and strip sack in just five games have made him a transfer target. Keeping him in Happy Valley is a must.
- LB Tony Rojas: A stalwart against the run, Rojas’s injury has highlighted his value. With two more seasons of eligibility, he’s a cornerstone of the defense.
- OL Anthony Donkoh: With experience at both tackle and guard, Donkoh is poised to lead the offensive line next season. His leadership will be invaluable.
- CB A.J. Harris: A transfer from Georgia, Harris has proven himself as a shutdown corner. If he stays, he could contend for All-Big Ten honors.
- TE Luke Reynolds: Stepping into the shoes of NFL-bound Tyler Warren, Reynolds has already shown promise as a sophomore. He’ll be a key target for Penn State’s young quarterbacks.
But here’s the million-dollar question: Can Penn State find a coach who not only wins games but also unites a fanbase hungry for success? And which of these candidates has the vision to lead the program back to national prominence? The answers will shape the future of one of college football’s most storied programs. What do you think? Who should Penn State hire, and what’s the biggest challenge they’ll face? Let’s debate in the comments!
